Justice Delayed 53 Years: Ex-General Sinclair Dies Without Conviction as Chihuío Massacre Plaintiff Highlights Biological Impunity

After 53 years, the justice system has delivered a definitive first-instance sentence in the Chihuío Massacre case, yet concerns over biological impunity arise as key perpetrators, including ex-General Santiago Sinclair, passed away without facing justice.

Justice Delayed 53 Years: Ex-General Sinclair Dies Without Conviction as Chihuío Massacre Plaintiff Highlights Biological Impunity

Original article: La justicia tardó 53 años y el exgeneral Sinclair murió sin condena: querellante por masacre de Chihuío advierte sobre «impunidad biológica»


After 53 years, the justice system has delivered a definitive first-instance sentence through the extraordinary visiting minister for human rights cases at the Santiago Court of Appeals, Paola Plaza, regarding one aspect of the so-called «Chihuío Massacre«. Marco Antonio Rubén Rodríguez, a retired lieutenant colonel of the Army, was convicted for the premeditated and completed murders of 17 peasants and workers, including a minor, from the Panguipulli Forest and Timber Complex. However, the plaintiff’s lawyer, Francisco Ugás Tapia, warned that due to «biological impunity», Santiago Sinclair Oyaneder, the head of the regiment, died without facing justice for his involvement in these crimes committed on October 9, 1973, in the Termas de Chihuío area, municipality of Futrono, in the Los Ríos Region.

In the ruling, the magistrate sentenced the former officer to life imprisonment for his role in the premeditated murders of Carlos Maximiliano Acuña Inostroza, José Orlando Barriga Soto, José Rosamel Cortés Díaz, Neftalí Rubén Durán Zúñiga, Luis Arnaldo Ferrada Sandoval, Eliecer Sigisfredo Freire Caamaño, Narciso Segundo García Cancino, Juan Walter González Delgado, Daniel Méndez Méndez, Sebastián Mora Osses, Pedro Segundo Pedreros Ferreira, Rosendo Rebolledo Méndez, Ricardo Segundo Ruiz Rodríguez, Carlos Vicente Salinas Flores, Rubén Vargas Quezada, and the 17-year-old minor, Fernando Adrián Mora Gutiérrez.

According to reports, the victims were detained, tortured, and executed with multiple gunshot wounds. Their remains were removed by the military and buried in clandestine graves with the intent of erasing all traces. Years later, some bodies were exhumed and identified through human skeletal fragments, including cranial pieces, extremities, vertebrae, ribs, and a total of fourteen patellas, alongside various personal belongings linked to the peasants.

In her ruling, Minister Plaza ordered the immediate placement of Rodríguez in preventive custody due to the severity of the sentence and the seriousness of the facts.

Santiago Sinclair Dismissal

Nevertheless, in her decision, the magistrate dismissed charges against Santiago Sinclair Oyaneder, a former Army general who was under investigation in this case and died during the processing of the case on December 28, 2025, at the age of 97.

His career was linked to the repression that followed the coup d’état on September 11, 1973, and a series of promotions under the aegis of dictator Augusto Pinochet, propelling him from regional commands to become a former deputy commander-in-chief of the Army, a member of the Military Junta, and an appointed senator.

Sinclair’s judicial history includes involvement in the Chihuío Massacre, his conviction in the Caravana de la Muerte (Valdivia Episode), as well as participation in operations in which the Army and Carabineros abducted and killed 15 peasants in Liquiñe on October 10, 1973.

In 2008, the judge Mario Carroza prosecuted officers for the kidnapping and disappearance of five members of the FPMR, incidents that occurred in 1987 by agents of the CNI in collaboration with the Army. The victims were thrown from a helicopter into the sea after a coordination meeting attended by the then-deputy commander of the Army.

In 2020, judge Álvaro Mesa prosecuted Sinclair for his responsibility in the crime of illegal coercion against nine political prisoners, in a case where the victims were accused in a setup dubbed «Plan Z». The investigation described transfers from the Valdivia Public Prison to the Cazadores regiment, interrogations, and the existence of a room where torture was inflicted, including electric shocks and beatings.

In 2023, his “mental illness” exempted him from serving sentences in a correctional facility.

Biological Impunity

Plaintiff Francisco Ugás Tapia from the Caucoto Law Firm stated that after 53 years of waiting, justice has finally provided a first-instance ruling in the Chihuío episode, “which accounts for acts that constituted a massacre against 17 victims who were executed, committed by personnel of the Chilean Army,”

He indicated that in these events, Rodríguez Olivares played a significant criminal role, for which he received life imprisonment as a custodial sanction, along with other accessory penalties, “for being the author of these qualified murder crimes.”

In his view, this sentence demonstrates that the passage of time and the age of the perpetrators are not impediments to prosecuting and punishing those who committed crimes against humanity during the dictatorship.

“This aligns with what international law mandates, which is also domestic law: our State must investigate, prosecute, and punish, with penalties proportional to the severity of the acts and effectively, these macro-criminals.”

However, the lawyer emphasized that “notwithstanding the above, we cannot overlook that the commander of the Regiment, Santiago Sinclair Oyaneder, remained unpunished, as biological impunity operated in his favor.”

“Situations like these compel us to demand a swift trial of pending criminal cases, so that criminals can be punished during their lifetime and serve the imposed sentences, preventing impunity in any form from protecting and favoring them,” affirmed the plaintiff, as cited in a press release.

Obtén tu Pasaporte y apoya a El Ciudadano

Elimina la publicidad, accede a contenido exclusivo y sé parte de la comunidad.

Elige tu plan

Turista

$1.990 /mes

 


Sin anuncios · Publica tus artículos

Ciudadano — TOP

$4.990 /mes

 


Sin anuncios · Publicar artículos · PDFs · Newsletter exclusivo · Favoritos

Diplomático

$10.990 /mes

 


Sin anuncios · Publicar artículos · PDFs · Newsletter exclusivo · Favoritos · Voz editorial

Cancela en cualquier momento  ·  Sin permanencia


Reels

Ver Más »
Busca en El Ciudadano